Why questions change when reported
When you ask a question directly, English uses inverted word order and auxiliary verbs: "Where do you live?" When you report that question, both of those things disappear. The reported version looks and sounds like a statement, not a question.
Two things always change. Sometimes a third does too.
→ He asked where she lived
(not: where
→ She asked if I was ready
(not: if I
→ She asked if I had met him
→ She asked whether I had met him
✓ She asked where I was going.
How tenses shift
The verb in the original question shifts one step into the past when reported. Here are all the shifts you need:
| Direct question uses | Reported question uses | Example | |
|---|---|---|---|
| present simple is / are / do / does |
→ | past simple was / were / did |
"Are you ready?" → she asked if I was ready |
| present continuous is/are + -ing |
→ | past continuous was/were + -ing |
"What are you doing?" → she asked what I was doing |
| past simple did / went / said |
→ | past perfect had + past participle |
"Where did you go?" → she asked where I had gone |
| present perfect have/has + pp |
→ | past perfect had + past participle |
"Have you eaten?" → she asked if I had eaten |
| will | → | would | "Will you help?" → she asked if I would help |
| can | → | could | "Can you swim?" → she asked if I could swim |
wh-questions vs yes/no questions
The two types of direct question are reported differently. The difference is in how you connect the reported clause.
Exercises
Select the correctly reported version of each direct question.
Report each direct question. Complete the sentence. Press Check when you've finished all five.
she asked where I lived
she asked if I had eaten